PowerTips

The Remodelers

Guide to Business

Behind the Scenes of an HGTV Pilot with John Huffman – [PowerTips Unscripted] Ep.06

Lights, Camera, Action! Getting the brand exposure of a TV pilot, aired on a national media channel like HGTV, can seem like every remodeler’s dream… But is it? What’s involved? Is it disruptive to your business? Do you get leads from it? Is it as exciting as it sounds?

In Episode 6, Victoria and Mark talk to John Huffman, CEO & Co-Owner of Black Door Renovation in Southlake TX. John runs Black Door with his wife, Elizabeth, and Rick Baker, a long time RA member, and together they focus on large-scale, high-end additions and whole house remodels.

John and Elizabeth, were approached by a production company in 2016 about pitching a show called “Lone Star Flip” to HGTV and their story of the ups and downs of that process is amazing and great insight to other remodelers considering a similar endeavor.

Often in business, timing is everything… and John talks more about how this opportunity occurred at about the same time as their merger with Rick Baker’s Stately Design & Renovation company.

John walks us through their experience and along the way Victoria and Mark cover:

  • How disruptive was it to your business?
  • How did this experience effect your brand and messaging for Black Door?
  • Did you see leads from it and were they qualified?
  • How did you handle the influx of leads?
  • How did you handle the pricing expectations we see mentioned on these types of shows on TV?
  • Knowing what you do now, would you do it again?

A great episode, not to be missed! Enjoy!

Episode Transcript

Mark: Today on Power Tips Unscripted, we talked to John Huffman, co-owner of Black Door Renovation, a high end residential renovation company in South Lake, Texas. John’s going to be telling us about his efforts to build a lead generating machine via an DTV home improvement show. Curious, so am I. Let’s get this week’s episode on the road.

Victoria: Hi, I’m Victoria Downing, and this is Power Tips Unscripted. Where we talk about tips, tactics and techniques to help you build a strong, profitable remodeling company. And I’m here with my co-host, Mark Harari.

Mark: Hello, everybody.

Victoria: And we’re really excited today because, you know, marketing and lead generation is such an important part of a successful remodeling business. Now, even though business has happened right now for most people, it doesn’t mean that you always get the kinds of prospects you want. So marketing to the right kinds of people, putting the right image out there is critical, wouldn’t you say?

Mark: Oh, this is my wheelhouse here.

Mark: Talking marketing, and we always talk about all the different channels that you can market through. And this is a this is a good, interesting topic that not very many people explore.

Victoria: So today we have John Huffman. And John has gotten really deep into the world of HGTV, which I know is one of the lead generation tactics that several of our members have tried over the years. So we’re going to get the inside story on everything that John expected to happen and what the results were of this whole this whole journey.

Victoria: So welcome, John.

John: Victorian. Thanks, Mark. I appreciate you guys having me on.

Victoria: Hey, we’re kind of excited to hear about this whole process. You know, obviously HGTV is like the big gorilla in the room for so much information about renovations and so on for our homeowners. So I’m interested in learning how you came to be involved in it and why you chose that tactic as one of your major marketing efforts.

Victoria: So talk about that for me a little bit, would you, John?

John: Yeah, absolutely. So it’s a wonderful question. As far as the why, I’d say maybe because we’re glutton for punishment a little bit. I know we in seriousness it you know, we started the company with a specific view towards trying to create a good solid brand in the market. When we when we were approached by a production company to film some test footage to pitch to Steve, it sounded like a very effective way to get our brand into a lot of homes relatively cheaply.

John: To be honest with you, we we were consumers of HDTV, I guess you could say, and we had been in business long enough where we kind of we’re seeing a disconnect between what was going on in TV and what was actually going on. In reality. I bet most people do. Yeah, but we knew we’re we’re in Dallas, Fort Worth, Texas, a suburb in Tarrant County outside of Fort Worth called Southlake, Texas.

John: It’s a very affluent community with a lot of opportunity for good, big remodels. And we’re two hours north of Waco, Texas, which I think most folks will know is the hometown of Chip and Joanna Gaines and Chip and Joanna on fixer upper right, a fixer upper fame there. Very their name is very solidly in pop culture now. It’s transcended, you know, construction and remodeling and transcended even HGTV.

John: And they have an amazing, solid personal brand. So having an opportunity to pursue something with HGTV and even having a 10th of that success was, was very interesting to us.

Victoria: So when you think about them and you think about what you were considering for yourself or hoping for for yourself, and that is you and your wife, right?

John: Yeah. That’s correct. So at the time, my company, Black Door Home Co was, you know, my wife and I were running, so we were a husband and wife team. I was focused on the construction, the production side, and she was really focused on the marketing and the design. So yeah, so we that was prior to our merger with, with another member, Rick Baker, but we so, so Elizabeth and I, you know, we were approached.

John: Well, I guess I’ll get to the story of how it all started if that.

John: You guys. Yeah. So we started our business actually in 26, early 2016. So we hadn’t been in business very long. Yeah, we were still pretty, pretty young in the whole industry. I’m a lawyer by trade, believe it or not. But don’t judge me by that. Don’t don’t hold it against me, okay?

Mark: We’re going to have to end the interview right now. Thanks for being here, John.

Victoria: No, we won’t hold it against you. We’ll. We’ll ignore that you were ever a lawyer in another life. Okay. Sorry. Back to the story.

John: I do appreciate that. I sometimes have to apologize. Courage. No. So when my wife and I started our business, you know, we really started it with a focus on, as I said, trying to create a good brand. Our industry is so fragmented. There’s nobody with any sort of significant market share. And really, there’s not a whole lot of penetration in the general public of any branding as far as legitimate remodels go in our area.

John: You know, there’s there’s some builders, some custom builders that have good, solid brand and I would say have solid brand awareness in the market. But really, unless and I think it’s the case everywhere, unless you’ve done a remodel project or explored one extensively, there aren’t very many, if any, remodel companies that just pop to mind as far as brand awareness goes.

John: So we started Black Door with that specific goal in mind and say, you know what? We lack an experience in the industry we can make up for in having a good, solid brand and pushing it out as far as we can as quickly as we can. So I’m on city council here in South Lake, and we’ve been very active in the community for a long time.

John: So we have a lot of good relationships and we got when we got the company started, you know, we really kind of pushed the brand out that direction and tried to try to, you know, get it out to other influencers in the community to try to, you know, get it into the general public. And and it worked. I think we were, you know, we were busy, busier than we should have been, I would say, and got a lot of jobs that maybe we shouldn’t have.

John: It turned out fine. You know, there was a learning curve, obviously, right. But I would say mid 2016 we got approached by a production company. And that production company, it was it was almost like it was almost like a cold call. It very much was. And they said they had seen some of my wife’s work, marketing work on Instagram and thought, yeah.

John: So social media was was very effective early on, and they had seen her work on Instagram and thought we might have a, a marketable kind of personal brand. Basically, we’re a husband and wife team doing remodel, and that’s what was hot on HGTV and continues to be.

Victoria: You know, when somebody like that approaches you, a lot of people would think, oh my God, this is a scam. What’s in it? You know what? It’s too good to be true. What’s the deal? How much is this going to cost me? Did that cross your mind as this as you were talking to these folks?

John: 100%. So when my wife showed me the email, my first thought was, well, yeah, go ahead and respond to that. And then let’s give the Prince of Nigeria our bank account number.

John: So and we didn’t think anything of it at all. And it was just one of those things I was like, okay, you know, go ahead and respond to it, but let’s not let’s talk about dinner tonight. You know, let’s let’s figure that out too. So we responded and she reached out and set up a time. And we set up a Skype call with with her.

John: And we did. We did a call over Skype. And then surprisingly, it was surprising to me. We got a call back a couple of weeks later and said, hey, you know, we’d like to do another sky call with with her boss, with the higher producer. So we did another one, and then we did another one with the head of the production company, and it just progressed from there.

John: And they said, you know, we like what we see. And we were just goofing off and being ourselves, and we didn’t think anything of it. And nor did we at any time think it was actually going to go anywhere. But, you know, maybe a month later, a month and a half later, they said, okay, so we are going to package this to and see if we can’t get anything going.

John: So again, didn’t think much of that because I imagine they get in. The reality is they do get hundreds of those every week. But then we got a call and said, hey, HGTV wants to film what’s called a sizzle reel.

Mark: What was it called a what?

Mark: Sizzle reel.

Mark: Yeah. So okay.

John: Sizzle reel. Yeah. So that’s as we learned that’s it was almost like a, like a tray, like a movie trailer for, but for kind of pitching our us as a couple and our company and the, the area as a potential show for TV. So they came down in October of 16 and filmed for three days. The full production crew, you know, there was a there was a producer, there was a camera crew, microphones, which my kids found endlessly entertaining.

John: They just they loved it. And we discovered our youngest, Anna, who’s now seven, is quite the natural in front of the camera, which scared me a little bit. Born performer. But we had a good time and you know, they cut it up and made a three minute video out of three days of filming, and he pitched it to TV and we got a call in December saying that they wanted to buy a pilot, which was really exciting.

Victoria: Well, so when you’re going into this, obviously you spent just just so far you’ve spent three days plus the other Skype calls, plus, you know, a lot of time. What were you hoping you’d get? Know you talked about brand earlier, but how does that translate to real results for the company. And what were you hoping? What were your goals when getting into this?

John: Yeah, that’s a great question. So yeah, again it’s you know branding is great, but it’s got translated into sales. Right. So as we were spending time on this, you know, it’s obviously taking time away from the business. And those three days were very difficult because at the time I had not I had not hired my first project manager.

John: I was still running all the jobs. I was very much in the first phase of our of our, you know, the life cycle of this company. So I was having to manage things from the phone and run a real business while we’re shooting this footage. Now, the goal as the brand Rose was growing is, you know, obviously to turn the attention we were getting into, into, into leads, into into good leads that we could go then close and produce the sizzle reel.

John: Really, that was all internal and that we knew none of that was going to go well. It was going to help us in the marketing, but I viewed it as we viewed it as an investment. And honestly, we didn’t know enough about the process to know what a long shot it really was. And I’m kind of glad because I don’t think I would have done it.

Victoria: Oh, really?

John: Yeah, I don’t think well, I don’t think I would have done the sizzle reel if I had known how or how speculative I got. And because once they pitched it HGTV, I mean, we were probably one of 40 or 50 that month that they picked and they picked 2 or 3, maybe not entirely sure of the numbers, but they, you know, there’s a huge funnel, right.

John: And and so we got into the pilot and, and then at that point, it’s still not a guarantee that the pilot is going to air once they film it. The pilot was incredibly time consuming.

John: And oh my goodness. It was very, very difficult. It was essentially it was 3 or 4 days a week, solid days of the week for eight weeks.
John: And yeah, it was, it was it was a distraction. At that time I had a project manager. So he was we brought him on in course of this to help with just the time management aspect.

Of it.

John: But, you know, it was also it was also resource draining. We had to, you know, we had to purchase the house and then we had to, you know, it was all of our capital.

Victoria: That only was it a a drain on your time resources, but you had to spend money to make this happen.

John: A lot of money.

John: A lot of money.

John: Yeah. So so when we talk about when you ask about my goals for this, what, you know, we did think a lot about that. And because because of the investment it was going to require. So we had to purchase the house and fund the renovation ourselves. And and again, it was very speculative because at that point we weren’t entirely sure the pilot was going to air.

John: Now, once the once the project was over and I was totally out of money, and then we started and then they started editing it and we got an air date. And that’s when really the attention that we were hoping started coming. And we got an incredible uptick in leads, an incredible uptick in jobs. At that point, I emerged my business with Rick Baker.

Who was.

John: Running a very successful, yeah, managed guy and running a very successful organization. He was my mentor in the group and had told me, hey, you, you got to come, JoEllen Ray, you’ve got to join. It’s going to make your business a lot better. And, you know, he was right about that. He was definitely right about that. But we had merged at that time when the pilot aired.

John: And so we had Rick and I spoke extensively. I mean, it was it was an everyday thing. How are we going to handle the leads that this is generating? Because not not only the volume, but also, you know, figuring out how to separate the wheat from the chaff. How do.

John: How do you really get quality leads in the door? Not just not just quantity.

Victoria: So.

Victoria: John, how did you feel about the whole, you know, conflict between what we hear about and what we see on many HGTV shows where they’re saying, yes, you know, we had a budget of 60,000 and we transform this whole house. And anybody who’s in the business knows that that is not a realistic number. Is that true? And how did you come to grips with that?

Victoria: Because wouldn’t that sort of be contradictory to the quality of the leads?

John: You’re exactly right. So, as you know, and every other remodel on this is listening to this knows HGTV is a double edged sword. You know, it drives demand for our services, but it creates totally unrealistic expectations. So a lot of people saw the work that we were doing. A lot of people saw the design that my wife had and it interested them.

John: But but yeah, just exactly what you said the conflict was that the budgets that you see are not realistic. And there’s some tricks that that, that they use to get the budgets down. But I mean, ultimately it’s TV, right? Yeah. It’s if you need to fudge a number, you need to punch a number that’s not, you know, when you watch the shows and they say, you know, we did this kitchen for a budget for the kitchen, $13,000, and they bring in a $2,000 faucet, a pretty good tip offset.

John: There’s some things that, you know going on behind the scenes, but they’re also they’re also opportunities for different trades and different subs to kind of provide their services for free. Those are called trade out. That happens to to average down the cost of these projects. But yeah, we did find that as we were getting into the the the wave of leads that came after the pilot error, we did find we were having to work harder to create expectations or to reset expectations.

John: Say, I know this is what you know. This is what people said we we were doing and people said, I know this is what the show said. All this cost, it was much more expensive than that. So there is a there is definitely a conflict there and we just have to we found we have to work harder on the front end to make sure that we are managing expectations as far as Costco, and to make sure that people understand that what they see on TV isn’t reality.

Victoria: So what, the leads were coming in the door. What were what were some of the results you got? Now, this is just after the pilot at this point. So what sort of results? What did you actually bring in sales? Was there a big uptick that you had hoped for? Was it as much as you’d hoped for?

John: There was, there was. So we you know, Rick and I saw company over the, over the summer and we did about double what we had projected. So we did almost a million and a half in sales the second half of the year. Wow. And we’re on track. We’re on track to do between 5 and 7 million this year.

John: Which which is great. Not only tribute all of that at HTV because we’ve we’ve certainly. Been very intentional in our marketing to the type of clientele that we’re looking for. But we do find we still get we still get some attention from that. And the branding, the branding aspect was was a home run. I mean, we we have better market penetration than I think we could have ever hoped for prior to the show.

John: So, but but we did see an uptick in Leeds and we’ve been able to sort through and find the quality leads that we were looking for. And at this point, you know, we’ve got our marketing strategy in place and, you know, the show, the show’s over. They decided not to not to pick it up, which I actually think is a blessing in disguise, to be honest.

With you. Why do you say that.

John: On the business? Well good question. So so the reason I say it’s a blessing in disguise that we didn’t get picked up. Really? You know, I talked about a funnel earlier, how we started from just being pitched by a producer, and we were probably one of them went down to the sizzle reel, the pilot, and then finally airing, I guess, the pot of gold at the end of the rainbow, in my mind, the entire time was to be able to, through the show, create a brand that we could grow into a very solid company.

John: So I knew that the show would end at some point, whether it was after a pilot or after, you know, five successful seasons and after the show is over. I wanted a strong, stable renovation company left standing, and we knew Rick and I talked about it a lot. Elizabeth two. We knew that if the show went, it was going to be very, very time consuming and we heard 5 to 6 months for a season and it’s pretty much full time.

John: Full time filming. Yeah, it was going to be very difficult. And again, a huge drain on capital if, if because we were pitched as a flip show, which means we needed to go buy houses and then fund the renovation. So and at the same time, Rick and I really are focusing on the merger and the merged company and doing what it does best, which which really I mean, it’s not flip houses, it’s doing big, gaudy, high.

John: So as Rick and I merge, you know, we saw the potential of our of black door renovation, the, the merged entity and doing these high end remodels, we knew that the show was going to be difficult as a distraction. And I think looking in hindsight, you know, we were kind of protected from that a little bit just by virtue of the fact that it was going to be hugely time consuming and.

John: You know, resource consuming and with no real guarantee of a pay out of hand. Does that make sense?

Mark: Yeah, John. So I’m just curious. So do they not pay you as talent. Do you get do you get paid for that? If the show were to be picked up.

John: They do they pay a per episode okay.

John: Kind of yes a stipend.

Mark: Right. And then it’s.

John: Sorry, Mark.

Mark: I’m sorry. So. And then it’s on you to. You got to buy the property and flip it and all that that’s on you.

John: That’s right, that’s right. And I think if you average out our stipend, I probably made about $0.08 an hour.

John: But no, that’s not where you make the money on the television. You make the money by.

John: That’s right. By bringing it and pushing your brand and creating the company afterwards.

Victoria: Well, so you have the pilot done. Are you able to use that pilot in your own marketing now going forward? Are you able to leverage that time?

John: Yes and no. So we you know, we we are open that we were on the pilot for HTB and that’s on our social media. And that’s still that still causes interest or create some interest. But you know, interestingly enough, I don’t have those conversations as nearly as much as as I did while the pilot was airing and right before and right after.

John: It’s so it’s not people aren’t finding us because of that, which is what I would expect. I mean, the pilot was focused on us flipping a house in downtown grapevine, which is a historical area. It’s an older house. It was from the 1950s and, you know, encountered a lot of problems that you find in older houses. And it was it was fun.

John: It was we did a great job with it. But it wasn’t it wasn’t the the kind of job that we’re really marketing for.

At this point.

John: So so while again, to go back to the branding, you know, I think the HTTP continues to kind of be baked into our brand and in the market awareness of our brand, but it’s not what is driving the lead to this point.

Victoria: So so the big question in hindsight, would you have done it again, knowing what you know now, would you have invested the time and the money to do the show, the pilot?

Oh.

John: That’s a wonderful, wonderful question. I think I would my my wife, she might. I might say something different. Honestly, I think I would because of where our company was and how young we were in the industry and what a boost it was to our to our company and to our brand. So, so I think I would do it, do it again.

John: I would probably do it differently as far as how I approach the project and, and how I, I try to use the attention maybe in more strategically, although we were very strategic in how we used it to, to, to, to boost the brand. But, but I think on balance it was a lot of fun. It really was it was a lot of fun.

John: It was good for the business, you know, it was hard at the time. But, you know, it’s kind of one of the things if I knew now, if I knew then what I knew now, I’m not sure I would not sure I would have committed to it. But but on this side I probably would.

Victoria: Okay, good.

Mark: Cool. Thanks, John. So, John, you know what time it is.

And now here’s the remodeled advantage. Lightning round.

It’s a trap.

Mark: All right, John, we’re going to put 60s on the clock and I’m going to start hitting you with some questions. You ready?

John: I’m ready. Mark, who’s ready to.

Ever be on.

Mark: We go, buddy. What’s your favorite business book and why?

John: So I love Patrick Lynchian, who’s a business consultant, and he writes all kinds of awesome management books. One of my very favorite called The Five Temptations of a CEO. And I think it’s one of the greatest leadership books and fables that I’ve ever read. So I’ll go with that one.

Mark: If you weren’t the owner of a high end residential renovation company. What do you think you’d be doing?

John: Well, I guess I’ll be boring and I’ll say, I’ll be a lawyer. I’m trained for.

Mark: What are you not very good at?

John: Yeah. So? So the cobbler’s kids have no shoes, right? I’m terrible about honeydew projects at home. Terrible.

Mark: Your room, your desk or your car? Which do you clean first room.

John: Because I have a beautiful wife that encourages me to do so. The desk in the car can wait.

Victoria: That was very diplomatic.

Mark: How would I be able to tell you were having a bad day?

John: I’m really quick to laugh. I’m quick to engage if I’m sitting quiet or not, not making eye contact and not not engaging, then something’s gone horribly wrong. So I’d say that.

Mark: Have you ever been told you look like someone famous? And if so, who?

John: Well, that’s a great question. So I taught Sunday school to bunch of high school for four years, and there are a couple of them that were convinced I looked exactly like Henry Cavill, the Superman guy. Right. And but not nearly with his physique. Also, the poor man’s.

Victoria: All right. That’s the end of that one.

Mark: All right. Good. Thank you. Thanks, John. You know, I think I’m going to have to put a side by side comparison of that in the show notes.

Victoria: Yeah. There you go. That was awesome. John, thanks so much for sharing your experiences. You know, people get approached and then it sounds like, you know, you’re going to be instantly famous and instantly transform your company. So we really appreciate getting the behind the scenes look. And and I’m glad that it paid off in terms of giving you the boost you were looking for.

Victoria: So before we wrap up, I want you to share five words of wisdom with our listeners.

John: I think this is six, but I’ll say work like your life depends on it. You know, there’s just really no substitute for hard work. But ultimately, you know, the loftiest ideas and the greatest plans and, you know, the most wonderful education and learning. It all boils down to, you know, grunt work and doing it at hours where other people aren’t.

Mark: Very good. Thank you for being here, John.

Victoria: Thanks so much, John.

John: Thanks, Victoria. Thanks, Mark. Appreciate you guys having me on.

Victoria: You know, you never know what’s going on behind the scenes at something like a TV show. Say that fast five times.

Mark: No, I was really, really interested to find out what he had to say. And, you know, it just amazed me that, you know, everything’s on him. He’s got to buy the house. He got to pay for all that stuff, man. What pressure to put yourself under. But, you know, at least he’s getting $0.08 an hour.

Victoria: You know, the thing that sort of struck me was the fact that when they were doing it, it really was appealing to a client that wasn’t the client they wanted. In the end. Now, it might have been the client that they wanted when they had their own remodeling company. But when they merged with Rick, who was stately design build and they had such beautiful, large projects, it just didn’t fit anymore at all.

Mark: Yeah, yeah. So, you know, one of my big takeaways from that whole thing was his five words of wisdom was like 7 or 8 words. So leave it to an attorney to not be able to just get to the point. He just said, it’s just everything an attorney does. It’s ten times longer than you ask it to be.

Victoria: Remember, he did move to be a remodel and remodelers are awesome.

Mark: Yeah. So all right. So yeah, I think another good episode in the Ken. What do you think?

Victoria: I think so too. And I think it’s time for Naomi.

Mark: All right, take it away. Naomi. Thanks for being here, everybody.

Victoria: Bye.

Share:

Hey there!

Login To Come In

Subscribe Now!

Arm yourself with the knowledge to take your remodeling business to the next level.

Search